At lunch last week with my clinical students the topic turned to which specialties they were considering for their future career. The senior resident (PGY6) on our service walked by and we asked her to join us. “Come sit down… we’re talking about how you choose a specialty.” She responded “You mean how a specialty chooses you.”
I believe that picking your specialty has far more in common with picking a spouse than anything else. All of us, at some point in our lives made a list of attributes we would like in our significant other… but… when we actually meet the person and fall in love, it’s almost a sure bet that who they are doesn’t really match the list… at least not entirely.
The wrong way to pick a specialty should be obvious – pick an “easy” specialty (or because the residency isn’t as demanding), or pick a specialty just because of what your income will be, or because it’s what you always said you would do. Just like picking who you will marry, choosing your specialty is not a choice that is made with lists of pros and cons. Some of the unhappiest doctors I know picked a residency because it was easy or because they thought the specialty would give them a better lifestyle… and then they were miserable because they hated the work.
Wear the White Coat
Almost every year I end up talking to a student who from the very first day of medical school was absolutely sure that he/she was going to be a surgeon. In choosing their rotations, they put surgery last – thinking that it would mean a better grade, better letters and a better chance for a good residency. They cruise through their other rotations superficially – interested enough to get decent evaluations and good grades – but never really engaged in the specialty. And then the unthinkable happens… they start their surgery rotation…. and they realize they don’t want to be a surgeon.
I tell students at the end of basic science that as they enter the clinics they should “wear the white coat”. When you are on pediatrics, be a pediatrician. When you are on internal medicine, be an internist. Don’t just think about it, try it on. When your attending asks you what field you are thinking about for your career, tell them that you are really interested in _____ (fill in the blank for the current rotation). It’s the truth…. you are interested. Show up every morning with the thought that this is the specialty you will be practicing the rest of your life. At the end of the rotation, you’ll have an honest understanding of the field… and you’ll be able to know for sure if it’s a good fit for you or not.
One other important thing to remember: there are more specialties out there than you will be exposed to…. The link below is the list of all boarded specialties in the United States.
Learn about specialties that sound interesting, meet physicians who practice them, and ask questions. You don’t have to be on a rotation to spend some time with a doctor in practice; most of them are delighted to have someone interested in the field spend some time with them. Email them and tell then you are interested and want to shadow them for a day or two.
How to Pick Your Specialty
I’ve watched the process enough to have a theory about how we pick our specialties. Here’s how I think it happens. The first thing that happens, as you go through your rotations, is you discover that you are more “medical” or “surgical”. I will warn you that it’s not predictable! Remember – somewhere over 70% of medical students end up in a field different from the one they predicted when they started medical school. The field of medicine needs both surgical and medical doctors. The two halves make up the whole, like the classic Yin-Yang symbol. And, like the symbol, every surgeon must have a little internist in them and vice versa if they are going to be a master in their field.
Once you are comfortable with your “medical” or “surgical” leanings, the next step is whether or not you want to care for the entire patient (e.g. general surgery, general medicine, family practice) or a part of the patient (e.g. ophthalmology, dermatology). Again, there is no judgment implied here – all the specialties are necessary and important. There’s one more branch in this decision tree… whether or not you want to work with children, adults or both. These are things you learn, not things you decide. I think my senior resident was absolutely right. The specialty chooses you. So how do you let it choose you? Listen. I don’t mean listen in the usual sense. Watch for the moments when you feel the tug to care for a certain kind of patient, notice when a role model makes the field seem appealing, pay attention when you get up in the morning and you can’t wait to get to the hospital. I don’t know of any better way to pick your specialty…. or let it pick you.
Thanks for this. I find it so much more enjoyable, even as a preclinical student, to just be open to what may be coming for me. It makes any bias or past propensity for or against certain material/fields so easy to forget about. I treasure the awe I continue to find in all of the new subjects. In less than a year, I will find awe in patients and the very beginnings of the practice of medicine. It is so exciting!
This could not be more true. During medical school, I used be amazed at the goal-mindedness of those classmates you met on day 1 who told you with great conviction they always wanted to be an Adolescent Nephrologist or Left Hand Surgeon; more often than not, they were ambushed by a specialty “choosing them” along the way.
A caveat to the answering the ubiquitous beginning-of-rotation career path question is to be true to yourself; I much rather hear “I don’t really know yet, but I’m enjoying X rotation so far” than King Lear’s sycophantic “gilded butterflies” who are ‘passionate about’ whatever they need to say to get a good grade…and then don’t follow through by trying on the white coat.
An interesting insight to previously-unthought-of options might also be gleaned from the likes of the Pathway Evaluation Programme from Duke ( http://www.smbs.buffalo.edu/RESIDENT/CareerCounseling/main_menu.htm ), who polled thousands of physicians and residents across the spectrum of specialties on what aspects of their practice gave them greatest satisfaction (dextrous tasks, work/life balance, multidisciplinarity etc.). You can rank all of these things and then get a personalised league table of “fit”. Certainly, this is no substitute for wearing the coat… but it does open up a brand new wardrobe of possibilities.
Did I mention stereotypes? http://bp2.blogger.com/_e85U4QbYG7s/Ru74v7u75xI/AAAAAAAAAbQ/AsnWxh3gh9M/s1600-h/12+medical+specialty+stereotypes+full.jpg
When I read this, I thought first of the sorting hat at Hogwarts. But a better parallel would be what Ollivander said to Harry Potter, “The wand chooses the wizard.” And choosing a specialty can be compared to choosing a significant other- you can rationalize it, but at its core the choice is visceral, not rational.
Too many students seem not to realize that a good physician needs to know things about medicine outside their primary interest area for many reasons. Your pateints will not always have only one problem. Once you’re a doctor, you will get questions from your family about everything medical. You also need to pass the several parts of the USMLE.
I am a final year medical student and im still very confused on how to chooose my specialty.please can any doctor in the house please advice me thanks
There are a couple of posts here… and you can also ask mentor(s). The plural is on purpose. Asking a group of people, particularly if they know you, is a good idea. At the end of it all, though, you have nothing but good choices. Don’t look back – all professions in medicine are noble. Once you pick one, dive in head first!
Thank you for this! I’m actually a vet student from Europe, but I want to go to the US for my internship and my residency. I will finish with my studies soon and still have no idea if I rather wanna be a surgeon or an internist. I’m very interested in both fields and I think I have good skills in surgery. On the other hand I don’t know if I wanna spent most of my time with a mask on my face bound to an OR. I really hope that during the rotation I will get a clear picture of what I want…
I love that you compared picking your medical specialty to picking a spouse rather than just choosing something that is convenient. I think that picking a career is something that should be done with care and a lot of thought. Because it can influence the lives of others, it would be very important to make sure that it is something that you love and care a lot about so that you don’t end up getting burnt out in the future.