The Well-Being “Movement”

I have had a blast for the last month leading a selective for a fabulous group of medical students who, as is usually the case, have been teaching me as much (or more) than I’ve taught them.

Those of us who choose to practice medicine have always known that along with incredible joys and successes, our profession comes with stress, sorrow, and even personal injury (physical, emotional, and spiritual). But in the early 2000s it became apparent to most of us that something had changed, a change that was leading to more injury, more suffering, and even deaths among our colleagues.

That realization marked the end of the “Era of Distress” and the beginning of “Well-being 1.0”, when we began to recognize, study, and teach about this crisis in medicine. (These terms are from Physician Well-being 2.0: Where Are We and Where Are We Going? by Tait Shanfelt) Wellness 2.0, the era where we begin to solve this problem, is described by Tait Shanafelt like this: “The scapegoating and finger-pointing that divided physicians and administrators in the Well-being 1.0 phase are replaced [in Well-being 2.0] with a mindset of physician-administrator partnership to create practical and sustainable solutions. There is acceptance that physicians are subject to the same human limitations that affect all human beings, with attention to appropriate staffing, breaks, and rest as a part of performance.”

Physician Well-being 2.0: Where Are We and Where Are We Going?

That’s an aspirational transition and, in my opinion and (more importantly) the opinion of my students, one that isn’t likely to happen without some major shifts in Medicine, Inc. (the term to describe the business of medicine used by my colleague Ricardo Nuila in his wonderful book,The People’s Hospital: Hope and Peril in American Medicine)

As we discussed the path forward, we all agreed with Vivek Murthy‘s statement in his New England Journal of Medicine article, Confronting Health Worker Burnout and Well-Being that this isn’t a problem that will be solved with more committees or more studies…. it’s going to take a huge shift in the way we think about our health care system.

“The time for incremental change has passed. We need bold, fundamental change that gets at the roots of the burnout crisis. We need to take care of our health workers and the rising generation of trainees.”

Vivek Murthy, MD

The “bold, fundamental change” we are going to need isn’t easy to pin down, but we circled around it as we wrestled with at least 20 topics during our two hour conversation. Among the topics we discussed, there were two that really stood out to me…

AI is not the answer (because we haven’t articulated the question)

Even though AI in medicine is mostly described as helping physicians, there is an added burden they brought up that I hadn’t thought about… Patients are coming in more informed (a good thing) but there is almost always misinformation mixed in with valid information. That means more physician time and emotions spent trying to disprove false information. (That led us to talk about about this great essay on why AI can make us better physicians, but is dangerous for medical students)

They recognized something else profound … if AI gives back time, who gets to fill that time? Will it just be filled with more patients by administrators, or will be add to desperately needed breathing room for those caring for those patients?

What else could be true?

One of the things that we kept returning to was the potential of the EMR to injure healers via 100s of “paper cuts” every day. They were way more up to date about this issue than I would have expected for pre-clinical students and they had a lot of tweaks they thought might improve the current EMR … Which is when I introduced them to a powerful question: “What else could be true?” Are we taking as a given that the EMR as it exists now is the only way we can keep accurate, professional records of the care we provide to our patients? What else might be possible? More importantly, why don’t we think about what else might be possible?

They were also concerned about the culture (referring mainly to senior physicians) who believe that it’s “impossible” to train good doctors any other way than they were trained (80-100 hour weeks and all the other sacrifices that are expected). That’s not surprising. Our “formal” concern with physician distress only took off 20-25 years ago. The people who were trained at that time are for the most part still practicing, and have passed on their views and their training to the next generation. But this was an easy example of why it’s important to ask what else could be true: “Results [from this study]: All countries reviewed limit the weekly working hours; North-American countries limit to 60-80 h, European countries limit to 48 h.”

The discussion of global differences in training led us to talk about medical systems around the world and how what we claim is “impossible” in the United States isn’t actually impossible. We talked about the Carte Vitale in France, and the system in Taiwan – acknowledging that no system is perfect, but we can learn from all of them.

We also realized that there is no system that protects physicians from moral distress. There will never be enough time or resources (in any system or any country) to provide all the care physicians feel needs to be provided, which inevitably leads to moral distress. But our healthcare system (in the United States) is unique in the world; We are the only medical system in the world that has profit built in as a feature of the system, which creates a different kind of moral distress.

The most important takeaway I had after our first week together is this: I’m not worried about the future of medicine… we’re in good hands. I’m sorry we’ve created such a mess for them, but this next generation of physicians is more than ready to heal the lives entrusted to them – and the system they will work in.

Stay tuned for next week… “What else might be true? – A new paradigm to understand “burnout”.”


Discover more from wellnessrounds

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply