Let There Be Rest (at least as much as possible)

I recently was invited to a meeting where a group of residents and educators were tackling the topic (and reality) of resident fatigue. We started by reviewing the ACGME Program Requirements. When it comes to mitigating fatigue, the ACGME requirements are (in my words):

  • Teach residents and faculty how to recognize fatigue, why it’s dangerous, and how to mitigate it. 
  • Make sure there are adequate places in the hospital to sleep when residents are on call. 
  • Arrange for alternative transportation for residents who are too tired to drive home.

They also list some strategies for mitigating fatigue; “…strategic napping; the judicious use of caffeine; availability of other caregivers; time management to maximize sleep off-duty; learning to recognize the signs of fatigue, and self-monitoring performance and/or asking others to monitor performance; remaining active to promote alertness; maintaining a healthy diet; using relaxation techniques to fall asleep; maintaining a consistent sleep routine; exercising regularly; increasing sleep time before and after call; and ensuring sufficient sleep recovery periods.”

All of these are great ideas, but it’s important to realize that there is an assumption behind them which is that fatigue is physical, and mostly the result of sleep deprivation. 

As someone who survived surgical training prior to the 80 hour duty hour regulations and who practiced for a long time, I know from personal experience that although sleep is foundational, there are a lot of different ways to be tired. It is true that physical fatigue, particularly sleep deprivation, is the primary reason residents, practicing physicians, and other healers are tired. But it’s not the only reason. Saundra Dalton-Smith, MD has thought deeply about this, and thinks there are seven different kinds of tired.

Source

When I saw the list of seven types of rest in Dr. Dalton-Smith’s talk, it reminded me of another image, one I saw in Beyond Burnout: A Physician Wellness Hierarchy Designed to Prioritize Interventions at the  Systems Level by Daniel Shapiro and his collaborators. If you haven’t read this paper, you should. It describes using Maslow’s hierarchy of needs to develop a model of physician well-being, a model that helps identify barriers to well-being (and what to do about them).

Source

It should be obvious, but it’s worth stating – to get to the top level (where you can achieve your full potential) you have to start at the bottom. If you are hungry, thirsty, or scared you aren’t ever going to be able to give or receive respect and appreciation. And without meeting the four levels of need below the top level you won’t be able to fully show up to heal patients and contribute.

Which brings me back to fatigue. 

I’ve known for a long time that fatigue is much more than just sleep deprivation.

I think most of us would agree that the soul crushing fatigue that comes with recurring moral distress is worse than the fatigue of a non-stop beeper when you are on call, which is worse than the fatigue you feel after an hour charting in the medical record.

So I took Shapiro’s model and asked this – What if fatigue can be thought of as a hierarchy? If the model makes sense, like Shapiro’s work, it should be able to guide us as we work to mitigate fatigue for our trainees.

 It’s a draft, but a new idea I think is worth exploring. Let me know what you think.

Portable Devotion, “Socialization”, and How to Eat Well On Call.

Portable devotion

What a fascinating journey this morning as I travelled 1500 years back in time (via the internet) to this medieval portable altar. 

On my first roll of the digital dice on this website that randomly links to other websites, I arrived at a database of portable medieval altars, created by a historian whose research interest is “portable devotion”. Lots to think about here…

“Socializing” an idea

I suspect the word has been around for a while, but I learned that “socializing” has become part of “business speak” in medical centers and hospitals, as in… “Go socialize that idea with them first.”

It turns out this new vocabulary is just a new way of describing what great leaders have known all along…you don’t know what you don’t know. 

Source

“Socializing” a new idea starts with determining who might want to “veto” your new idea and then meeting with them, not to persuade them, but to learn from them. With each meeting you learn more which lets you refine the project and, at the same time, allows your organization to evolve with you. 

The best thing I learned is that the concept now referred to as “socializing” came from the Japanese concept of Nemawashi (根回し)… “Nemawashi literally translates as “turning the roots”, from ne (根, “root”) and mawasu (回す, “to turn something, to put something around something else”). Its original meaning was literal: in preparation for transplanting a tree, one would carefully dig around a tree some time before transplanting, and trim the roots to encourage the growth of smaller roots that will help the tree become established in its new location.” (Wikipedia)

#CallFood

There are lots of people who spend nights in the hospital to care for others… physicians, nurses, techs, and many others. 

Especially for trainees who work long hours, eating well when you are on call is not easy. There are usually few (if any) options available in the hospital, and when you are exhausted it’s hard to prepare and bring your own food. 

But eating well is really important …. not just nutritionally, but emotionally as well. Here’s a link to the system I’ve found works the best, but deciding that Diet Coke, graham crackers, and cereal are not major food groups is the critical first step. 

p.s. I post recipes that meet the “pizza rule” (less time to cook than it takes to order a pizza) on Bluesky, Facebook, and Instagram with the hashtag #CallFood. 

p.p.s Here’s the recipe for my breakfast tacos (which are also the best 2am #CallFood you will ever have). 

A Parable For Our Times

Sometime in the early1900s a surgeon performed colectomy for a patient who suffered from schizophrenia. Post-operatively, not only was the patient’s colonic pathology cured, but it appeared that their schizophrenia was as well. 

Not too long after, another surgeon noted the same thing… he had operated on a patient with schizophrenia who was less psychotic after removal of part of their colon. These two anecdotes became a theory… which led to a large number of schizophrenic patients undergoing removal of their (healthy) colons.  

This doesn’t make sense, right? Except that it turns out that major trauma (like a big operation in the early 1900s!) can lead to a temporary relief of psychosis in some patients with schizophrenia. In other words, it probably would have been just as effective – and just as temporary – to induce a high fever…which was also a form of treatment for schizophrenia in the early 1900s. (Ebaugh et al., 1938)

There’s a parable here, one that helps us navigate dangerous, unproven theories that are proposed by (usually) well-meaning people …

Portrait of Baynard Holmes in 1889, from Wikipedia

In the early 1900s there were many well-respected physicians who thought schizophrenia was caused by “autointoxication”.1 Baynard Holmes, Professor of Surgical Pathology and Bacteriology at the College of Physicians and Surgeons in Chicago, was one of them. His foray into the surgical treatment of schizophrenia was personal; His son Ralph had his first psychotic break as a second-year medical student. Holmes abandoned his other academic work to concentrate on “curing” schizophrenia. He first published a paper showing that schizophrenic patients had delayed transit in the colon and hypothesized that stool “stuck” in the cecum was therefore the cause of schizophrenia.(Holmes, 1920)

Diagram of an appendicostomy – Source

Holmes operated on 22 patients, creating an appendicostomy to flush the stool out of the colon.(Noll, 2006) There was a 10% mortality rate… and one of the 2 patients who died was his son, Ralph.(Davidson, 2016)

Henry A. Cotton, Sr, was another authority who promoted, and took advantage of, the autointoxication theory of schizophrenia. He was a psychiatrist who oversaw, and then performed (!), colectomies on over 200 patients with schizophrenia. He reported a success rate of over 80%…. and a mortality rate of 25-30%.(Davidson, 2016) 

In 1923, a group of physicians did what needed to be done from the beginning – a randomized controlled trial. Not surprisingly, there was no difference in outcome between patients treated with surgery and those who did not have surgery.(Kopeloff & Kirby, 1923)

It took a long time for these dangerous operations to stop, despite the proof that they didn’t work. We can only imagine how many hundreds of patients underwent this futile and very dangerous procedure before it was finally abandoned. In today’s world of rapidly available communication it takes 17 years for new evidence to change clinical practice. (Morris et al., 2011) We can assume that in 1924 it took longer than that. In addition, there were physicians (like Henry Cotton) who ignored this new data and continued to remove healthy colons from schizophrenic patients because they personally benefitted from doing the operation, either financially or because of their reputation. (Davidson, 2016)

So what “instructive lesson or principle” does this parable illustrate?

You may add to this list, but I think we can start with these…

  • We can be blinded by our desire to end suffering (especially if it’s someone we love)
  • As human beings, our desire to heal can limit our ability to be objective about outcomes… which is why we have clinical trials (and the scientific method).
  • And finally (and unfortunately), there are charismatic but evil people who take advantage of people who are afraid and/or suffering. 
Source
  1. By the way, there are remnants of this theory still with us today in the form of “detoxificaiton” of the body by cleaning out the GI tract with diet, purging, and/or enemas. (It still doesn’t work…) ↩︎
  • Davidson J. Bayard Holmes (1852–1924) and Henry Cotton (1869–1933): Surgeon–psychiatrists and their tragic quest to cure schizophrenia. J Med Biogr. 2016;24(4):550-559. doi:10.1177/0967772014552746
  • EBAUGH FG, BARNACLE CH, EWALT JR. PSYCHIATRIC ASPECTS OF ARTIFICIAL FEVER THERAPY. Archives of Neurology & Psychiatry. 1938;39(6):1203-1212. doi:10.1001/archneurpsyc.1938.02270060093003
  • Holmes B. Dementia Praecox: The Insanity of the Young. Dementia Praecox Studies: A Journal of Psychiatry of Adolescence. 1920;3:105-138.
  • Kopeloff R, Kirby G. Focal infection and mental disease. Am J Psychiatry. 1923;80:1490191.
  • Morris ZS, Wooding S, Grant J. The answer is 17 years, what is the question: understanding time lags in translational research. J R Soc Med. 2011;104(12):510-520. doi:10.1258/jrsm.2011.110180
  • Naumann DN, Marsden MER, Brandt ML, Bowley DM. The Bouffant Hat Debate and the Illusion of Quality Improvement: Annals of Surgery. 2020;271(4):635-636. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000003623
  • Noll R. Infectious insanities, surgical solutions: Bayard Taylor Holmes, dementia praecox and laboratory science in early 20th-century America. Part 2. doi:10.1177/0957154X06059446

Shohei Ohtani, Attention Spans, and Elevation (Gratitude on Steroids)

How Shohei Ohtani became a super star…

Sahil Bloom shared this image in a recent newsletter, along with an explanation of how Ohtani used the “Harada system” to become the superstar he is.

The chart Ohtani created as a freshman in high school to meet his goal of being drafted 1st in the Nippon Professional Baseball League.

The story of the Harada system is delightful. It was developed by Takashi Harada, an junior high track and field coach in Osaka, Japan who realized that his young athletes needed more than just drills and strength training to succeed (in all ways). He developed a system for them to define their own goals and actions, and then used it to take his last place team (out of 380 schools!) to 1st place – a position they held for 6 years. 

Source of this photo (thank you again, Austin Kleon)

Increasing our attention spans

Our ability to pay attention is how we accomplish the things that are important to us, whether it’s being one of the best (if not the best) baseball players in the world like Shohei Ihtani, or finishing a book that has been lying fallow on a computer for too long (Mea culpa).

Thinking about how to better pay attention led me to this post, which summarizes and shares a 4 minute video from Daniel Pink with his 5 step plan to improve our ability to pay attention👇

Set a baseline 

See how long can you read a book until you are distracted

As you add steps 2-5 (below), repeat to monitor your improvement

    Eliminate distractions

    Make where you work a “no phone zone”

    Close tabs and anything else on your computer that might distract you

    No notifications on any device! 

      Create a focus ritual

      It doesn’t matter what it is, but it matters that it exists

      “It’s like hitting play on a playlist your brain already knows.”

        Take breaks and move

        “Think of your brain like a toddler… It melts down if you don’t give it snacks and naps.”

          Reconnect attention to meaning

          Take the time to articulate the “why” of what you doing

          “It turns a chore into a choice.”

          “Purpose fuels persistence.”

            Outside article that is the source of this photo

            Elevation (gratitude on steroids)

            In 2000, Jonathan Haidt defined elevation, which he described as “a warm or glowing feeling in the chest [that] makes people want to become morally better themselves.”  It’s the “thrill we experience when we see someone act with courage or compassion”, and it’s most likely the source of prosocial contagion.

            And how do we promote elevation, which sounds like just what we need in our society right now? According to Nancy Davis Kho, it’s by developing an ongoing practice of gratitude. 

            “Research published in 2015 in Frontiers in Psychology found that an ongoing practice of gratitude basically rewires our brains to reward us for the positive perceptions we have of the people around us. That begets more gratitude and “elevation,” a lovely scientific term defined in a 2000 article by social psychologist Jonathan Haidt as “a warm or glowing feeling in the chest [that] makes people want to become morally better themselves.” Pour me some elevation, barkeep, and make it a double!”

            The Thank-You Project by Nancy Davis Kho, 

            Thanksgiving Cornbread

            Every year at Thanksgiving, I make my great-grandmother Sallie’s cornbread recipe. She and my great-grandfather were “dirt farmers” who lived in Oklahoma during the depression. This bread, some beans, and vegetables from their sustenance garden (if there were any), was all they had for dinner most nights.

            As I mix the ingredients for this cornbread (and then use it to make stuffing), I can’t help but ponder their life…how hard it must have been and how, as my ancestors, they made my life possible.

            I don’t want you to just sit down at the table.
            I don’t want you to just eat and be content.
            I want you to walk out into the fields
            Where the water is shining and the rice has risen.
            I want you to stand there far from this white tablecloth.
            I want you to fill your hands with mud, like a blessing.

            -Mary Oliver

            Mix together with a big spoon

            • 1 cup cornmeal
            • 1/2 cup flour
            • 1 tsp soda
            • 1/2 tsp baking powder
            • 1/4 tsp salt

            Make a large “hole” in the middle of the dry mixture with the spoon

            Beat one egg with a fork, add 1 tablespoon of oil (which is what my great-grandmother used) or melted butter (which tastes better IMHO) into well in the middle of the dry mixture and mix with a fork

            Add 1 cup of buttermilk

            Let rise while heating the oven to 450 degrees (about 10 minutes) with your cast iron skillet in the oven.

            Gently whip the batter down with a fork

            Pour any excess oil from the pans into the batter and then pour the batter into the hot cast iron skillet.

            Bake 20-25 minutes (until a toothpick or knife comes out clean)

            So that’s my great-grandmother’s recipe (and yes, the photo at the top of this post is of her and my great-grandfather). This recipe makes the right amount for a weekday dinner but it doesn’t make enough for Thanksgiving. So I did the math to make enough for everyone (and the stuffing, and breakfast the next morning!) If you don’t have enough cast iron skillets, no worries. Use muffin tins, cake loafs, whatever you have.

            The recipe is the same but starts with melting a stick of butter in the microwave (It’s supposed to be 7 tablespoons but a stick of butter = 8 tablespoons and I can’t imagine a little extra butter hurts!)

            Dry ingredients:

            • One bag of cornmeal (2lb)
            • 3 1/2 cups of flour
            • 7 tsp of baking soda
            • 3 1/2 tsp of baking powder
            • 2 1/2 tsp of salt

            Wet ingredients:

            • 7 eggs
            • “7” tablespoons of butter (see above) – or use oil if you prefer
            • “7” cups of buttermilk – the batter should pour but not be thin
            Photo by Mary Brandt

            Nurdles, Forest Bathing, and the Secret to Life

            The Secret to Life

            If you don’t know about the amazing Kate Bowler… you’re welcome! Her take on the “secret of life” (yup, for real) is one of the best I’ve ever heard. (Click on the image to hear it)

            Nurdles

            Link to the Houston Public media report (and source of this photo) 

            “Tiny plastic pellets called nurdles – each about the size of a lentil – are washing up on Texas beaches in alarming quantities. These pre-production plastics are the raw material used to make everyday items like bags and bottles. But when they spill during manufacturing or transport, they escape into the environment, becoming one of the most widespread sources of microplastic pollution.”

            Turtle Island Restoration Network

            This is a scary situation I knew nothing about. These little pieces of plastic “act like tiny sponges, absorbing toxic chemicals such as pesticides and heavy metals”. So it’s not just that we take in microplastics by eating fish that have confused these objects with food, we also consume the poisons the nurdles have absorbed.

            A reminder that forest bathing is wonderful (and so easy)

            I spent some time yesterday in a park near my home and, while there, decided to try the Japanese practice of shinrin yoku, known in English as “forest bathing.”  (Which is therapeutically known as sylvotherapy!) 

            It’s a practice that involves all five senses, one by one, intentionally… 

            • Listening to sounds, birds, insects, wind in the leaves
            • Touching the ground, the trees, and the leaves.
            • Smelling flowers, plants, the dirt  
            • Seeing plants, birds, animals, clouds.. 
            • Tasting by breathing through your mouth

            If you work in a hospital or another building, a small green area or a single tree will suffice. 

            Even a few minutes can be transformative.  

            The Tools We Hold: The Digital Phone

            We have powerful tools on our digital phones, particularly in medicine. But the relationship with our phones is complicated…and not always beneficial.

            The first time I ever came across the word alexithymia was in this New York Times opinion piece about digital phones by Steven Barrie-Anthony. As a physician, I love learning new clinical words with Greek roots – in this case “a” for not, “lexis” for words, and “thymos” which means “feeling” or “spiritedness”. Alexithymia (a word invented in 1970 by psychotherapists), is also known as “emotional blindness”, and means not being able to recognize your emotions. 

            Dr. Barrie-Anthony noted that the “vast majority” of his patients were experiencing an “alexithymic fog” due to the “gravitational pull” from their phones and social media, a condition that affected “the most important aspects of who they are, their relationships with others and how they move through the world.”

            So what? 

            pexels-photo-4526398.jpeg
            Photo by I’m Zion on Pexels.com

            Do we really have agency when we get pulled in by the gravitational force of our phones? For our non-work related time, we pick the app…but then we fall into the dopamine feedback loop of whatever game we’re playing, or algorithms that are foundational to social media. 

            I think it matters more that I’ve realized, and not for the reasons I thought:

            Being used by the tools of the digital world is different from using them as tools because it separates us from our authentic emotions.  

              “One constant I’ve found is how technology brings a kind of alexithymic fog — alexithymia being the condition of having difficulty identifying or being able to express one’s emotions. This isn’t universal, and the emotions we’re pushing away aren’t always the same. But it happens in a startlingly consistent way.”

              Steven Barrie-Anthony

              We need our emotions. 

                To tackle the problems of technology we have to return to our emotional lives for their own sake, and not always leap to doing or changing or fixing. This is the only viable pathway if we are to remain in touch with our humanness and to preserve love, empathy, emotional and spiritual richness, and the capacity to create art and music that reflect our inner lives.

                Steven Barrie-Anthony

                I have yet to experience awe in the digital world. 

                  “When medieval Christians gathered in cathedrals, the soaring architecture and stained glass were designed to lift their thoughts toward the divine. The shared narrative included an image of the good life that directed one to love their neighbor as oneself. Today’s digital architectures are designed with a different purpose – to keep our attention firmly earthbound, focused on consuming content and generating data. The “infinite scroll” isn’t just a design feature; it’s a spiritual technology that trains us to value quantity over quality, novelty over depth, reaction over reflection.”

                  Tripp Fuller
                  Churchill, Manitoba, photo by Mary L. Brandt

                  p.s. Here are the first two posts in what I hoped would be a planned series on “The Tools We Hold”:

                  The Tools We Hold: The Senn Retractor

                  The Tools We Hold: The Allis Clamp

                  Roman Roads, Ordination, and #BanTheBouffant

                  This is cool research.

                  You’ll enjoy exploring this online tool (assuming you are enough of a history, map, and/or liberal arts nerd). It’s an interactive map developed by a multidisciplinary group of European researchers for scholars (and the rest of us) to explore 299,171.31 km of roads built during the roman empire. 

                  Ordination

                  Tomorrow is my ordination in the UCC… which is not just a genuine calling but, for me at least, is also a form of resistance in a world that right now has a lot of “not-love”. I’m so grateful.

                  Cloth hats for the win!

                  I hope the tide is turning, but due to a misdirected effort to improve quality (see this article, which is one of my favorites!) many operating rooms still force surgeons, anesthesiologists, nurses, techs (and everyone else who enters the OR suite) to wear bouffant hats. 

                  I was delighted to read this recent article showing yet another reason to wear cloth hats in the OR… they were studying communication and camaraderie in the OR and showed that cloth hats with names and roles on them helped with both. 

                  Fractal Fluency

                  Clouds are not spheres, mountains are not cones, coastlines are not circles, and bark is not smooth, nor does lightning travel in a straight line.  

                  Benoit Mandelbrot, in his introduction to The Fractal Geometry of Nature
                  Earth’s Most Stunning Natural Fractal Patterns

                  The Fractal Foundation describes a fractal as ““a never-ending pattern that repeats itself in different scales. This property is ‘self-similarity’”. These repeated patterns are found in the “roughness” of nature and the structure of our bodies, creating an order which is thought to be the subconscious reason we have such deep emotional responses to the beauty of nature.

                  Human beings are fascinated with the symmetry and beauty of fractals despite (or perhaps because) they are mathematically incredibly complex. Benoit Mandelbrot, a mathematician and polymath, coined the term “fractal” while working to understand the “roughness and self-similarity” in nature. Well, actually, his first work was looking at the “wild randomness” of the stock market… but as he explained, his formal work at IBM for 35 years allowed him to ask deeper questions.

                  “Dramatically referred to as “the fingerprint of life,” their repetition of patterns across multiple scales forms the basic building blocks of many of nature’s patterns ranging from clouds, trees, and mountains through to our brains, blood vessels, and lungs.”

                  Fractal Fluency: Processing of Fractal Stimuli Across Sight, Sound, and Touch, Taylor et. al. 2024


                  Most of us haven’t heard of fractals… but knowing about them allows us to see the world and our studies in medicine through (literally) a different lens. How cool is that?

                  The power of patterns

                  A Clot of Hematologists, the Full Moon, and Eco Divina

                  Here’s what caught my eye this week..

                  This post about collective nouns from Jono Hey

                  I’ve always thought we missed a great opportunity in medicine for collective nouns…  A flow of urologists? A clot of hematologists? …😂

                  Day Light Savings Time. It’s easier for your body clock to adjust when flying east to west through time zones which is why it is easier to adjust to the “fall back” to standard time that we just experienced. There are lots of theories about how daylight savings time got started and why. It’s also known that a) it’s better for us to not go back and forth between daylight savings and standard time and b) if we have to pick one or the other, standard time is the one to choose. 

                  Eco Divina. Lectio divina is a powerful tool for meditation and/or prayer, a four step practice that uses the words of a text (usually a sacred text) to lead you to insight and inspiration. (If you haven’t ever tried it, here are some great instructions. Although these instructions refer to the Bible, any text, from sacred writings to poetry can be used. I had heard of visio divino, where art serves the same purpose… but eco divina was new to me (at least by that name). Like sitting with words, or with images, eco divina is sitting deeply with something in the natural world in a way that reminds you of the beauty of creation (and your part in it). 

                  The moon. Make sure you go outside tonight and look at the moon. It’s a supermoon and worthy of a little “eco divina” (aka awe).

                  I love this app to know when the moon rises and sets (and in which direction).

                  The best hospital signage I’ve ever seen.

                  I was recently part of a survey team that visited Savannah Children’s Hospital and I have to share how patients and families find their way in their hospital! 

                  There is a “tree” in the entrance that defines the color scheme for the entire hospital (green = surgery, brown = diagnostic imaging, blue = ER/ICUs…etc ). There are also symbols associated with each color. 

                  (the family gave me permission to take this photo)

                  Then you follow the path!

                  Every corridor has tiles that confirm you are still going in the right direction based on the colors.

                  We often forget that 21% of adults in the US are illiterate, which means they won’t be able to read signs pointing them to different areas in the hospital (or any building for that matter). In addition to being incredibly effective, this attention to design is also an act of kindness. 

                  Still thinking about Game 7 of the World Series…

                  I have never seen a game like it and probably never will again…  

                  (From the Irish Examiner, posted on Bluesky)